I did not like it at all/I did not even finish it.
I did not like it at all but I finished it.
It was alright. I finished it. I didn't hate it.
It was alright. I almost found something to like.
It was pretty average.
It was pretty average but there was a lot I liked about it. However, something held me back.
I really, really enjoyed it.
I loved it but something was holding me back from giving it a 5/5.
I absolutely loved it and have put it on my favourites shelf.